Study Hall

Supported By

Spec Wars: Looking Inside Loudspeaker SPL Specifications

While it might be possible to attain stated max levels from that box, it'll probably only happen once... and it might catch fire.

The past decade has seen a significant rise in the deployment of active loudspeakers, mostly 2-way designs housed in molded plastic cabinets. With modern processing and plenty of class D power, it’s possible to get remarkably good sound quality from these lightweight models.

They will also go surprisingly loud, with manufacturers routinely claiming in excess of 130 dB from a single loudspeaker! With that in mind, let’s take a closer look at some of these claims and examine whether they’re plausible or indeed possible.

There will also be some tech talk, mostly relating to loudspeaker cones and what happens when feeding several kilowatts into one.

But first, a couple of definitions.

Xmax: a loudspeaker cone’s linear travel. Different manufacturers define it in different ways, but it’s generally accepted that a given loudspeaker will start sounding bad when driven past Xmax.

Xmech: the mechanical limit of a cone’s travel. Permanent damage (torn suspension, smashed voice coil, folded cone, etc) is extremely likely if a loudspeaker sees enough power to hit Xmech.

Current State Of Affairs

There are currently a lot of manufacturers, and they’re all competing for your cash. If there’s a simple, easy-to-grasp number that makes their product look better than others, they’ll try to inflate that number as much as possible to increase sales.

Here’s a car analogy: the maximum sound pressure level (SPL) rating of a loudspeaker is similar to the maximum speed of a car. The problem is that it’s very easy to measure a car’s maximum speed – there’s a dial in front of the driver telling him how fast he’s going.

On the other hand, the maximum output of a loudspeaker is much more difficult to measure because it depends on a significant number of factors, including the test signal itself. Most of the time we tend to trust the manufacturers and don’t try to verify performance claims.

What if I told you that Car A has a maximum speed of 160 miles per hour (MPH), and Car B has a maximum speed of 170 MPH? Car B is faster, right? However, would you still want to buy Car B if the engine immediately caught fire when it reached 170 MPH?

This is the sort of thing we’re talking about when a standard 12-inch, 2-way loudspeaker has a stated SPL of 136 dB. Indeed, it might be possible to attain that level from that box, but it’ll only happen once, and it might catch fire.

In the interest of not naming names (since there are many loudspeaker companies that play this particular game), I’m going to set out an example system that utilizes quality off-the-shelf components, powered with sensibly-sized amplifiers, and then see how it might compare to the specifications produced by the industry at large.

Example System

To help save the environment, I’m not going to do the destructive testing myself. Instead, let’s run some simulations.

The 12-inch midbass cone driver I’ve chosen is a proven unit from a noted manufacturer. It has a 4-inch voice coil and comes with a stated 1,000-watt continuous power rating, 98.5 dB sensitivity, Xmax of 7.3 millimeters (mm) and Xmech of 26.5 mm. It’s a very good driver and can be found in top-end active loudspeakers.

Read More
VUE Audiotechnik Unveils e-352 Nano Installation Loudspeaker At InfoComm 2017

The high-frequency portion is a 1.4-inch compression driver with a 3-inch pure titanium diaphragm. It’s rated for 110 watts of continuous power, and has 109 dB rated sensitivity when loaded on a 90- by 40-degree horn. We’ll choose our amplifier so there’s plenty of headroom for short-term peaks, delivering 2 kilowatts (KW) to the cone driver and 220 watts to the compression driver.

Supported By

Celebrating over 50 years of audio excellence worldwide, Audio-Technica is a leading innovator in transducer technology, renowned for the design and manufacture of microphones, wireless microphones, headphones, mixers, and electronics for the audio industry.