Study Hall
Sponsored by
Audio Technica

To PA Or Not To PA? The Conundrum Of Deciding When To Deploy Sound Reinforcement

Analyzing when, where and why a system may -- or may not -- be necessary, and in fact, do more harm than good...

By Karl Winkler September 5, 2019

Since we’re all in the sound reinforcement business, one way or another, the question asked in the title of this article might not seem very relevant. But the truth is that there may be as many times that we either don’t need a PA system at all or end up using less kit than we initially anticipated.

As both a musician and a “sound person,” I’m often confronted with problems (or at least decisions) on this topic. Let’s look at some examples.

400 Weddings, Anyone?

I play music at about 30 weddings per year, on average, so over the last 14 years I’ve been to more than 400 of them. Many are held in smaller, intimate venues where a PA isn’t required for the officiant nor for the string quartet playing ceremony music.

When we get into larger venues or if the event is outside, the issue of a PA system often comes into the equation. The quartet is still almost never miked, which I generally prefer, so that the inevitable problems with amplifying stringed instruments is avoided.

But really, it generally just isn’t needed. Acoustic instruments were developed over centuries to carry sound to the back of the room. Need it louder? Bring more musicians.

However, a PA for the officiant is another story. For rooms seating, say, 50 or more people, and certainly in outdoor settings, a reinforcement system is almost always required so that all the guests can hear the vows, readings, and exchange of rings. Along with the PA come the problems – the most common of which include: improper wireless system setup, loudspeakers not facing the right way and/or not properly covering the audience, a loud acoustic problem such as a fountain that’s running during the ceremony, and a lack of wind protection for the mics (if outdoors).

These problems beg the question (at least in my mind): Why use a PA if it’s not going to be implemented correctly? It’s along the lines of what my dad would say: “Any job worth doing is worth doing right.”

I realize that often, the micro PA systems are provided and set up by hotel staff, park employees, wedding planners, and the like. In other words, usually not sound professionals. I’m sure if any of us are at an event where these things are happening, we all cringe and share in the sound person global spirit of “what the heck?”

What can be done about this? I’m not sure I know the solution, other than when possible, point out simple fixes that might make a difference. This can be a delicate proposition, though, and I for one don’t want to suddenly be responsible for the DJ’s rig when I’m there with another job to do (play the viola) or even attending just as a guest. Still, sometimes a friendly suggestion can make a difference.

Finding Solutions

At one particular wedding outdoors at a very exclusive venue, I noticed the wireless mic was cutting out from time to time. I looked over and saw that the receiver antennas weren’t raised up and splayed; rather, they were in a folded position.

And, of course no one else seemed to notice anything, although everyone there must have been at least mildly annoyed by the voice dropping in and out. I went over, raised and splayed the antennas, and voilà (see what I did there?), there were no more dropouts.


Read the rest of this post

1
2


About Karl

Karl Winkler
Karl Winkler

Vice President of Sales at Lectrosonics
 
Karl serves as vice president of sales/service at Lectrosonics and has worked in professional audio for more than 25 years.

Comments

Have something to say about this PSW content? Leave a comment!

Scroll past the ”Post Comment” button below to view any existing comments. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Dale Swezene says

Karl,

Indeed, you have seen allot and "Been there. Done that.
Bought the ball cap and the T-shirt"!

I applaud your ability to cut to the heart of the matter. Not like a salesman trying to make a buck off other people's hopes and failures but more like one gifted with the ability to see root issues and work solutions with a strong and creative problem-solving capacity. That is a rare talent but so needful in the Pro Sound business.
Live Long and Prosper. Thanks for sharing your insights.

Karl Winkler says

Dale, thanks for the kind words! Much appreciated. Please do stop by and say hello at one of the trade shows - next up - IBC, followed by AES in NY. Cheers!

Tagged with:

Subscribe to Live Sound International

Subscribe to Live Sound International magazine. Stay up-to-date, get the latest pro audio news, products and resources each month with Live Sound.