Church
Sponsored by
Yamaha

Church Sound: How To Ruin Your Mix

Is the audience listening to the song and a solid mix or just a barrage of inputs, with each one fighting to be the loudest?

By Andrew Stone September 14, 2018

Image courtesy of Silentpilot

Here’s the prevailing thought on my mind this weekend as I’m spending a great deal of time behind the mixing console: It’s relatively easy (simple, even!) to completely ruin your mix.

This isn’t a new revelation for me or anything, just one of those simple thoughts flittering around the edge of my consciousness as I work this weekend to NOT ruin my own mix.

So, fellow ruiners, allow me to present this thought: What are your multitude of inputs accomplishing? Are they enhancing what’s happening on stage and complimentary to the vibe of your event OR are they assaulting the senses of your audience and making it confusing to listen to?

A lot of live mixes I hear in some churches these days are cluttered with tons and tons of textures and layers. What’s notable here is that most of these never sounded very good in the first place and are extremely frustrating to listen to in the actual mix. Sorry to break the news to some of you, but this cluttered mess is all it took to ruin what might have been a beautiful mix.

This article is provided by Church On The Move.

Allow me to confess, I know how to COMPLETELY ruin a mix.

How many of you have used triple-mic’d toms and snares in a live mix? Oh yes, I ruined that mix to the extreme. It was lame though that I was the only one in the history of audio to get the memo that mic’ing the top head, bottom head, and the shell of every individual drum was the only way to accurately capture the perfect tonality of a live drum kit.

Perhaps it was just that I was way ahead of my time?

I’ve also been quite a pioneer in my liberal use of chaining together multiple analog sub-mixers. I mean, who wouldn’t kill for all the extra headroom from having multiple gain stages from different brands of consoles all working in concert with one another? Bet you didn’t know about THAT awesome pro trick! Well, neither did anyone else, it turns out. I ruined those mixes in short order.

While I’m having some fun here to prove a point, here’s the reality: sometimes, amidst all these worthless inputs and all this gear patched everywhere, the heart of the actual song gets lost. Simplify it!

Ask yourself: Can one keyboard part suffice live even if it took 7 parts on the record? Can a lead guitar line mixed over a good rhythm guitar rock for a live mix or are you just duplicating what you saw some band do in a controlled studio environment because it looked cool?

The human ear can only handle so much crap before it begins to internally dampen the barrage. Simplify your mix and make every single element count.

Ever wonder why some of the most singable songs were created by 3 and 4-piece bands? No matter what you think of bands like Coldplay, U2, Keane, or even AC/DC, none of them have very complex input arrangements when it comes to their live mixes. And the crazy thing is that their basic combination of inputs usually results in an extremely simple and effective mix where every element can be heard cleanly and distinctly. DEFINITELY something I’d rather listen to.

Say ‘no’ to a ruined mix today. Lighten up on the potential of another auditory onslaught by simplifying what elements you are using to bring your mix to life. The listeners will thank you.

You can read and comment on the original article here. See the rest of Andrew’s articles on ruining a mix here.


About Andrew

Andrew Stone
Andrew Stone

Production Director and Senior Audio Engineer, Church on the Move
Andrew Stone is the Production Director and Senior Audio Engineer at Church on the Move in Tulsa, OK. His audio, production, and financial experience gained from the last 28 years spent touring, watching his back in the entertainment business, and now focusing on doing things the right way in church has given him a unique, and sometimes unorthodox, perspective to his approach towards production. He’s been a key part of changing the culture behind COTM's live events and he loves sharing his knowl...

Comments

Have something to say about this PSW content? Leave a comment!

Scroll past the ”Post Comment” button below to view any existing comments. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Mark says

Great article. Simple but to the point. lived it this summer at our festival.a 3 pce and 4 pce band, well rehearsed and knowing their place in the group sounded great. I then had to mix 4 acoustic guitars with bass, keys, and drums jamming together. Couldn't make it sound good at all. thanks for the reminder.

Mike Aldridge says

Great points! I can’t tell how many times the church praise band wants to sound just like the recording with lots of tracks. All this gets in the way of great musicians pouring their hearts out in a performance. If your goal is to sound like the recording, just playback the recording. The best performances almost always occur when there are no tracks.

Tagged with:

Subscribe to Live Sound International

Subscribe to Live Sound International magazine. Stay up-to-date, get the latest pro audio news, products and resources each month with Live Sound.