Study Hall
Sponsored by
Audio Technica

Using All-Pass Filters To Improve Directivity & Magnitude Response

Demystifying an overlooked tool that can be used to yield a more linear phase response

By Charlie Hughes March 15, 2013

We are all familiar (or at least should be) with a low-pass and high-pass filter.

As the name implies, they pass one part of the audio spectrum while attenuating the others. They are the basis for loudspeaker crossovers.

As with any analog filter there is phase shift associated with the change in output magnitude of these filters.

Examples of these are shown in Figure 1 (below) as fourth-order Linkwitz-Riley filters. If we were to add the output of these filters back together, essentially combining them with a unity gain mixer, we would get the response in Figure 2 (also below).

Here we see that the magnitude response is perfectly flat; it passes all portions of the audio spectrum, thus the name all pass.

However, the phase response is not flat. There is phase shift associated with this all pass behavior.

This phase shift is due to the contributions of the low pass and high pass filters that were combined (mixed). There are, of course, other ways to construct all-pass filters.

Figure 1 – Magnitude and phase response of fourth-order Linkwitz-Riley low-pass and high-pass filters (Note: only one phase response curve is visible because they are both identical) (click to enlarge)

They can be defined mathematically, just as low-pass and high-pass filters can be. They can be of different orders (i.e. first, second, third, etc.) and have specific alignments (Butterworth, Bessel, Linkwitz-Riley, etc.).

These alignments are not defined by the shape of the magnitude response at the corner frequency of the all pass, as we typically think of low-pass and high-pass filters, but by the shape of their phase response at the corner frequency. Low-pass and high-pass filter alignments can also be defined this way.

One difference to remember about all pass filters is that for each order there is 180 degrees of total phase shift. Low pass and high pass filters have only 90 degrees of total phase shift for each order. The importance of this distinction will become clear later.

Figure 2 – Magnitude and phase response of the summation of the fourth order Linkwitz-Riley low-pass and high-pass filters from Figure 1 (click to enlarge)

Now that we have a basic understanding of an all-pass filter, let’s see how one can be put to good use. Suppose that we have a two-way loudspeaker system comprised of a high-frequency horn and dual 12-inch woofers as illustrated in Figure 3

The horn is located at the top of the baffle. One woofer is directly below the horn. The second woofer is directly below the first. This is a fairly typically configuration.

To keep things simple we will model these components as point sources. This will make it easier to see anomalies in the directivity response of the system when the individual sources are combined.

Figure 3 – Example dual 12-inch woofer, two-way loudspeaker (click to enlarge)

The horizontal symmetry of our example loudspeaker assures us that nothing spectacular will occur in the horizontal plane. Having the sound sources displaced vertically will yield some interesting behavior.

Since all of the good stuff will happen in the vertical plane we will be looking primarily at vertical directivity maps and a few polar plots.

The nice thing about a directivity map is that it allows us to look at the relative level of different radiation angles at all frequencies at the same time, whereas polar plots only allow us to see the relative level of different radiation angles at a single frequency.

Ideally we should see the same level at all frequencies and at all angles since we are using point sources (which have no inherent directivity).


Read the rest of this post

1
2
3
4


About Charlie

Charlie Hughes
Charlie Hughes

Managing Director, Excelsior Audio Design & Services
 
Charlie Hughes has worked at Peavey Electronics and Altec Lansing, and currently heads up Excelsior Audio Design & Services, a consultation, design and measurement services company based near Charlotte, NC. He’s also a member of the AES, ASA, CEA and NSCA.
http://www.excelsior-audio.com

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Tagged with:

Subscribe to Live Sound International

Subscribe to Live Sound International magazine. Stay up-to-date, get the latest pro audio news, products and resources each month with Live Sound.

Latest in HOW!