ProSoundWeb.com - Click to return to PSW Home
 
 

Drums without drummers: Can this really work?

Go To Page

1 2
Go To Page


OK, you all know the drill. It’s time to lay down the drum track for your future Grammy Award-winning song, but there’s just one tiny little problem; no live drummer within a 50-mile radius of your studio.

Or how about this one? You’ve managed to post bail (again) for your drummer, only to find out that he had to sell his acoustic kit to pay this month’s rent.

No problem, you think to yourself, I’ll just plug in my Drum-O-Matic 5000 and it’s a go! After all, drum machine technology has come a long way in recent years, and we all know about the improvements in sampling since the Drum-O-Matic 3000 was first released.

So you get your little black “drummer in a box” hooked up, program all your parts the way you always wanted your drummer to play them, and record your homage to John “Binary” Bonham. Everything is perfect, except for one little thing… your drum tracks sound like cat butt.

Before we continue, please let me share something with you. Although I spend most of my musical time locked away in the DAW dungeon, and these days I'm lucky if I get to play my drums once or twice a week, I am at heart a drummer. I love the drums. To me, every great recording begins and ends with a great drum track, and likewise, every crappy recording begins and ends with a crappy drum track.

It seems that rarely do songs get placed in the "classic recording" file without containing a well-executed, beautifully captured drum track. Unfortunately, many home recordists do not have Jim Keltner's home number, nor do they have the budget, space, or tolerant neighbors for an acoustic kit in their home studios.

I should also say that in addition to my passion for all things drum shaped, I also have a fondness for drum loops and electronic based rhythm tracks. If executed properly, these types of sounds and grooves can create a certain type of atmosphere that is unique to their makeup. On the flip side, canned samples, bad midi tracks and boring old drum machine patterns can also suck the life out of any song faster than anything.

So, at this point you’re probably asking yourself, “can I create great rhythm tracks when live drums are simply not an option?” Is that not-so-cheap Drum-O-Matic 5000 on my desk worthless? Will this article contain actual tips on building useable “non live” drum tracks? Why did so few people actually enjoy the movie “Joe Versus. the Volcano”?

The answers are yes, no, yes and I don’t know, it happens to be one of my all-time favorites!

Tip #1 - How to get the most out of your drum machine sounds

First let’s start with the samples themselves. Sometimes, you don’t want a snare drum to sound like a snare drum as much as you want it to sound like a garbage can filled with BBs being struck with a frozen herring. While I can appreciate the need for such a sound, for the sake of this article, let’s assume that most of us are typically looking to recreate natural, acoustic drum kit and cymbal sounds.

That said, often the collection of standard single note “hits” provided in your drum machine can leave much to be desired. If your particular drum machine can import samples from another source, such as your PC, your possibilities are endless. There are piles of great CDs on the market, full of beautifully recorded drums for your sampling pleasure. You’re bound to find pleasing kick, snare, tom and cymbal samples to fit any style.

If you didn’t have the money for the Drum-O-Matic 5000, so you opted for the less-expensive 3000 model without inputs…don’t panic, you still have options! I’ve found many great software drum machines available for the personal computer that function just like their hardware big brothers.

My favorite happens to be a shareware product called LeafDrums. It’s very easy to operate, uses WAVs as it’s native file source, and has a great price point! Even if you’re stuck with the stock samples that came loaded in your drum machine or keyboard sequencer, you still have a good chance of finding a handful of sounds that can be very useable.

Tip #2 - How to program effective drum machine parts.

Let’s look at levels and panning. To me, nothing sounds more revolting than a drum machine track with ultra loud cymbals and toms that are panned hard right and left. This is not how an actual acoustic drum kit sounds when played live, nor is it typically recorded and mixed in this fashion. Sampled cymbals and toms are usually the weakest link in the chain, so be careful of how much attention you draw to them.

Also, cymbals usually do not have to be very loud to cut through a mix. Try and let the frequencies in which cymbals resonate “react” to your mix before boosting their volume. This will most likely take practice and much restraint. Toms, as well as cymbals, should be used sparingly, and should also take a back seat in the volume department.

The kick and snare should almost always be the loudest drums in the mix, and should usually be panned to the center. As I mentioned before, beware the urge to “over pan” the toms and cymbals. Most drum tracks (electronic or acoustic) sound best when mixed in mono, or slightly panned, with a stereo reverb applied. Now that your samples are selected, and their levels and pans are set up in a very musical way, let’s look at how to build a great sounding drum part.

When all else fails, use the KISS method. No, I’m not referring to the fire breathing, painted face, rock legends, although much can be learned from Peter Criss’ simplistic drum style, I’m talking about the K.I.S.S. method - Keep It Simple Stupid. Try to avoid programming “busy” and overly complex drum parts. Less is usually more, and you’ll most likely find that simple drum parts sound more natural, and will sit much better in your mix.


 

Email this story to a friend.

Next Page

 

 

 

Headlines

 
 
 
     

 

 

PSW Live

 
 

Wedge World! What's up in the world of monitors

The Old Soundman takes on "kids" these days

Inside scoop on properly advancing live shows

Stalking the "wild" Yamaha PM1D digital console

 
     
 

Community

 
 

Need more info? Ask your community!

Live Audio Board

Rec Pit

Contracting Forum

Lighting Forum

PSW Chat: Info & views from industry leaders

Ken's Links: Get where you need to go - fast!

 
     


© copyright 2008 ProSoundWeb.com
169 Beulah Street, San Francisco, CA, 94117 USA
Voice: 415 387 4009  |  Fax: 415 752 8144
Send comments about this site to webmaster@prosoundweb.com