|
Be sure to check in with Harvey in his
PSW RecPit Forum.
|

|
 |
Over the years, I've heard people
tell me a lot of things that they believe to be true, but
aren't. They hear it from other musicians and pass it on and
pretty soon, people start accepting it as absolute fact.
The actual truth gets buried in history and that's the way
legends are born. It's charming, but inaccurate. Let's examine
some of these beliefs.
|
Bass drum ports: There are a lot of drummers that cut a
small hole (usually around 4 to 6 inches in diameter) in their front
head to "port" their drum. Somebody may have told them
that this tunes the drum (like a bass reflex speaker) to improve
the bottom end. Is it true? Yes and no.
Cutting a hole will provide a vent which can be tuned to resonate
the air inside the drum, but that's what the second head does anyway
- it's like a passive radiator, driven from the pedal head. Putting
a hole in the front head is kinda like putting a hole in your speaker
to port your hi-fi system.
So, why do drummers put that hole in their drums? Primarily to use
as an opening for a kick drum mic, without removing the head entirely.
A lot of drummers still print the band's name on their drum head
and that's important to them. That hole is important when you walk
into a studio to record. Live drummers saw their studio counterparts
using the hole and thought it looked cool, and adopted it.
Where the hole is located is very important, but not for any reason
you'd normally think about. It should be above the center line of
the drum, so that a short mic stand will work, and the mic stand
boom arm angle will let the engineer position the mic to point directly
at the spot where the beater hits the head.
The hole diameter should be around 6 inches to allow for various
size microphones. The center of the hole should be above the center
line of the drum, so that the entire opening is in the upper half
of the drum. Any 6 inches opening above the 9:00 to 3:00 line will
work.
Tubes are better than transistors: When transistors first
appeared, their distortion characteristics were very different than
tubes. Once you exceeded their output range, they simply gave up,
all at once and distortion went straight up very quickly. A transistor
amp which hit 100 watts at .05 distortion might put out 110 watts,
but at 35 percent distortion. A tube amp distorted slower and more
gracefully, often generating 2nd and 4th harmonics - which made
the sound even better.
The newer breed of MOSFET transistors were able to mimic this kind
of distortion, and the gap narrowed. With the new breed of computer
modeling amps, and some of the new DSP chips, the gap between tubes
and transistors is getting even narrower.
Tubes are noisier than transistors: Nope, it depends on the
circuit. You can build ultra-low noise tube circuits if you're willing
to take the time to do it right. And let's get rid of the tubes
won't reproduce high frequencies myth too. For many years, tubes
ruled the high frequency roost in the megaHertz range. The main
advantage to transistors over tubes is less heat, less susceptible
to shock and vibration, and now, lower cost.
There's no difference in cables and cords: Somewhat true
for speaker cables, once you get past the teeny size wires. Not
as true for guitar and audio cables. Bad shielding, high capacitance,
and poor construction can seriously degrade your sound in any cable
carrying low level signals. There are now even some wire companies
selling "directional cable," which is pure bull. All just
hype.
Different batteries sound different: Hmmm. Some people swear
they can hear a difference in batteries. I remain sceptical of their
claim. Some batteries DO put out more current then other batteries
and that MIGHT change the sound but I think different batteries
of the same actual voltage and peak current output should sound
the same. The jury is still unconvinced on this one.
A condenser mic is the best kind of mic: Best for what? If
that was really true, they would use nothing but condenser mics
in major studios. They don't. EVERY studio has dynamic mics, like
the Shure SM 57, the AKG D112, the Sennheiser 421, and usually several
ribbon mics and a wide assortment of general purpose mics. Why?
Because there is no such thing as the ONE perfect mic for everything.
For big ballads, it's hard to beat the sound of a great big diaphragm
condenser mic like the old Neumann U47, which now sells for around
$10,000 in primo shape. But even that mic occasionally gets beat
out by a Shure 58 or an old ribbon mic for some voices or some songs.
A good engineer doesn't go by price - he/she will pick whatever
works best for that particular sound.
PA amplifier wattage should match PA speaker wattage: Usually
you can double the wattage of the power amplifier to prevent clipping.
But if you're going to be playing loud, invest in a good stereo
compressor to go across the output of the mixer to prevent huge
spikes from blowing the speakers.
Guitar amps and speakers: 4 ohms, 8 ohms, or 16 ohms; is one
impedance better than the others? Impedance is simply the working
load the speakers put across the amplifier's output terminals. Maximum
safe power transfer occurs when the amplifier is correctly matched
to the speaker load. On stage, multiple speakers will give you more
output, compared to a single speaker and provide increased power
handling, but that isn't important in the studio. Many of the big
groups use a little 15 watt amp with a single speaker to record.
Speakers can be wired in many different combinations so that is
why many amplifiers have impedance switches on the back of the head.
Which impedance is best? Any of them will work fine as long
as the head impedance is set correctly - it depends on the speaker
configuration you're using.
Electric bass - how low does it really go? The main output
of a bass E string is primarily around 84Hz, not the 42Hz most bass
players imagine. The reason is simple; the string length is too
short to produce much fundamental. Yes, it produces some 42Hz, but
most of the sound is an octave above that.
Which brings up the next question; how do you get more bass out
of a system? It's very simple - you need to move more air. Low
bass must move more air, so the answer is more power (to make the
speakers you have move further), more speakers (so that each speaker
doesn't have to move as much), or a more efficient ported or horn-loaded
cabinet (so that the port and/or horn adds more air motion).
Find out more about Harvey and Indian Trail Studios at http://www.itrstudio.com,
and be sure to visit his
Rec Pit Forum.
|