Blog: Road Test

Hardware reviewed and tested by seasoned pros.


Road Test In Process: Mackie HD1531 Three-Way Self-Powered Loudspeaker
The kickoff to an ongoing Road Test of a brand-new entry in live sound loudspeakers from Mackie
+- Print Email Share Comments (2) RSS RSS

Mackie describes the HD1531 as a “15” High-Definition Powered Loudspeaker System”.

Yep, it’s got a 15” woofer, and it’s a three-way system, and it’s powered. Now what’s all this about being “High Definition”? I suppose I could try to explain it, but it might be easier if you just go here (pdf) and get the Mackie explanation.

The ordinary every-day non-HD attributes of this powered loudspeaker include 900 watts of power with an 1800 watt peak. Power is divided 700/100/100 (900/200/200 peak) into the Lo/Mid/Hi sections. There is a three-band EQ section that can be turned on and off as needed.

A noteworthy feature of the built-in EQ is that the total boost/cut of each band is 3 dB. I like this. It’s useful, but it does not give the inexperienced user enough rope to hang themselves. The mid band sweep range is from 100Hz to 8kHz with a Q of 1.5. It has a pole cup so you can mount it on a stand and 12 fly points. At 96 pounds, it’s at the top end of what you’d want to put up on a stand.

Cabinet construction is of 11mm birch plywood finished in good ‘ole basic black. Fit & finish is top-notch. The grill is a bit on the thin side, so I don’t recommend using this speaker as a backstop. No, not even for slow-pitch softball.

This is just a brief general description of the product so you know what I’m talking about. Details can be found here on the manufacturers website.

So how does this thing sound? Lemme tell ya…

First, let me say that I have used the Mackie SRM450 and SR1530 quite a bit, and I find that when used for what they are designed to be used for, I find them to be very useful products. I also find that when asked to perform beyond their design limits, they tend to fall short, often with disastrous consequences. This however, is the fault of the user, not the products.

.

My first use of the Mackie HD 1531 was in my back yard for a celebration of my son’s high school graduation. I used just one, and although it was not a very demanding application, I found listening to CD playback of a wide range of music all day to be very pleasant.

Next, I brought them to the club where I am the regular house sound guy. The room is on the small side, with a capacity of about 200 people. This size room is typical of the rooms where these speakers would get a lot of use. The room books a lot of bands that play music on the ‘harder’ side, but my plan is to use them for the ‘80’s cover band on a Thursday, and put the regular rig back up for the weekend.

The speakers worked out so well on Thursday, I decided to use them for the weekend with the heavy bands, and give them a true beating.

Like a lot of small club installations, there are issues with the installed system. In this case, The loudspeakers I am taking down are very good. The problem is that when properly splayed, the pattern is too wide for the room, so I have to choose between overlapping the horns or bouncing sound off the walls. The 90 degree pattern of the Mackies is narrower than the (properly splayed) 140 degree of the usual house speakers, but the installed speakers have a much higher output capability.


Comments (2) Most recent displayed first
Posted by kelly carson  on  06/21/10  at  10:19 PM
Do NOT buy these speakers!!!! We bought the Mackie HD1531 speakers new from Guitar Center. We were so excited after reading reviews on them. I had them less than 2 weeks and after 5 gigs one of the speakers was cutting in and out during our performance outside in 85 degrees. It was in front of thousands of people and sounded horrible. We thought the cables went bad, so we went out and bought all new cables for everything. The very next gig, we set them up outside and the 1 speaker will not come on. The thermal protective had kicked in gear and would not come on for anything. It was only 92 degrees and we found that it has to be 180 inside the speaker to shut down. Anyway, it never worked and we were stuck with using only 1 speaker all night for the whole gig which was a mess. We notified guitar center and they said it was faulty wire in the speaker. They did not have another pair at that store and sent us to Guitar Center in Arlington, TX. They hasseled us at this location about exchanging them and after arguing awhile, they finally gave us what they said was a new pair in the box. We got home and openend them the next day and found that they gave us used one, that were missing the new sticker and was all scratched and banged up on the bottom front. Plus missing all the power chords. So they sold us someones returned speakers and said they were brand spanking new. So now we are stuck with 2 speakers that do not work. We called the store and don't want to come and pick them up and want us to return them to the store which is quite far. We have another gig 1 day and desperate to have goood speakers. We are going to push to get a full refund and would not buy these speakers again. Hopefully we can find some other speakers out there that are better quality.
Posted by EMLIOL  on  11/26/09  at  07:32 PM
I WANT TO SEE VIDEOS
Back to top
Post a Comment

Name:

Email:


 View comment guidelines

Remember me

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Please type the 3rd letter of the word "microphone":



ProSoundWeb Book Store 

The Hal Leonard Recording Method - Book Six: Mixing & Mastering
Music Pro Guides
By Bill Gibson

Making the instrument and vocal tracks sound their best, then making them all work together- everything you need to know to make the perfect mix is in this book. You’ll then learn how to take that perfect mix… View this book

The Reel World - 2nd Edition
Music Pro Guides, By Jeff Rona

The Songwriting Sourcebook
How to Turn Chords into Great Songs, By Rikky Rooksby

Visit the PSW Book Store