Replicating The Vocals Of Queen’s “Bohemian Rhapsody”
A discussion about the classic Queen recording - did they do the choral parts themselves, and if so, did they use any effects to achieve the sound?
+- Print Email Share Comments (2) RSS RSS

Reply by ccgreg
Wasn’t it recorded on a Stephens 2-inch 40-track? If so, because of the incredible small track width, phase alignment was almost impossible, which made ping-ponging sound very bad. I’ve done it with extremely poor results.

Reply by mwalker_mw
As a tip to the question of the original poster, try to get ahold of the cast recording from “We Will Rock You” - it’s a West End stage production based on Queen music. The final number is Bohemian Rahpsody done by a full chorus live (I’m pretty sure, but you never know these days) on stage.

No, it doesn’t sound like the original recording, but it is a good showing of how to do something similar with a large chorus rather than extensive looping. By the way, the recording is a live multitrack, so it isn’t great, but you should be able to get some ideas out of it. Brian May and Roger Taylor were fairly heavily involved in the creative process as well, I understand.

Reply posted by heef
An article in Sound on Stage magazine several years ago had a story on the remix of “BoRap for” 5.1. Has a nice quote from Brian May too. All the extra high falsettos are by Roger. Brian and Roger make up a fair amount of the opera section too. Apparently vocals were still being tracked on the day of mixing.

Rob Schnapf tells me that Roy Thomas Baker used a Stephens Electronics tape machine. Whether this was one manufactured by Stephans, or a 3M modified by Stephans, I don’t know. I do know that “A Night at the Opera” was one of the first 24-track recordings, so it was obviously recorded on a 24-track.

Reply by dwo
There’s no real trick to achieving those vocals.. .it’s just #6 cattle wire with the tri-barb configuration, 10-inch barb spacing. Just adorn the singer in an appropriate fashion.

Some use this in conjunction with a run of electric fence wire, hookup is on a low voltage 100 amp slo-fire power supply set to gap on a 4 second interval, partly to let the deep surge caps recharge, but also to avoid singeing the singer with back-to-back DC whacks.

The high voltage/low ampere ones work better and are less cruel to the animal, but when they spark they make a distinctly audible ‘snap’ that is inappropriate for audio work.

Don’t be shy, man. If you want results, you gotta pay for ‘em. There simply isn’t a more effective inspiration for a singer than employing his genitalia as the dielectric between a sharp piece of metal and a sharp surge of DC.

Reply by doc dave
Is it worth mentioning 10cc’s “I’m Not In Love” in this thread? It is sometimes discussed alongside “BoRap” because of its amazing vocal overdubs. Noteworthy, too, that the only engineering/mixing/production credits are to “10cc”.

Among other things, I take it patience and perseverance are required in large measure. Come to think of it -  would a choral group give you the same feel as one or two voices recorded ad nauseum?


Comments (2) Most recent displayed first
Posted by Roelf Backus (Netherlands)  on  06/02/11  at  09:35 AM
One more note about multitracking stacked vocals.

It was done earlier but first started in a professional way with Les Paul’s recordings of the vocals of his wife Mary Ford in the 50’s. The were also the main example for the vocals and harmonies of the Carpenters as produced by Richard Carpenter.

I think there should be a few more

-Perfect intonation

-The same timing

-Good pronounciation

-A perfect musical memory to recall: how and what did we sang in chorus number 5 and 14 ?

Voices or a way of singing to blend the harmonies together. If you have a ‘solo’-voice it stands out too much.

-Family/relatives with the same timbre in the voices: Bee Gees, Beach Boys, Carpenters, Ryan Dan (twins !), or record it completely on your own: Billy Joel - The Longest Time, Richard Carpenter - Time (album).

Examples of voices that blend: Birtles & Goble (Little River Band), Peter Cetera (Chicago), Roger McGuinn & Dave Crosby (Byrds), Graham Nash & Steven Stills (CS&N) …and of course there are a lot more, but mostly high pitched, ‘thin’ voices like those of the Queen members.

I personally think Richard and Karen Carpenter (brother & sister) had it all: perfect intonation, timing, timbre and musical memory. And they could stand each other and work together for a long time.

Posted by Jo McArthy  on  02/17/11  at  02:28 PM
The RTB recorder is an original Stephens.(not a modified 3M)
Commenting is not available in this weblog entry.