A Practical Guide To Good Bass: Part 1, Acoustical Concepts Of Subwoofers
Part 1 of an ongoing series focusing on subwoofers - how they work in various arrays, concepts and techniques for getting good bass, and more
+- Print Email Share Comments (8) RSS RSS

In sound systems, it would be terrific if loudspeakers worked like spotlights: find the loudspeaker boxes with the right directional patterns, aim them where you want sound to go, and you’re done. Of course, that’s not the way it works, especially for bass. 

Ordinary bass loudspeakers are very nearly omnidirectional over their working ranges, but when you stack up a few of them, the pattern becomes more directional and more complex. Imagine if lights worked that way—a bare light bulb would illuminate the whole room, but four of them in a row would only light up some parts of it. 

To make things worse, when you use multiple woofer stacks—stage left and stage right, for example—it produces wave interference (also called “comb filtering”), causing peaks and nulls in different places in the room at different frequencies. If light worked that way, then when you lit up a room with two white lights spaced some distance apart, the room would be illuminated with a rainbow of different colors.

Even beyond that, there’s the problem of reverberation, which adds its own kinds of confusion and coloration in the time dimension.  That effect that doesn’t even have a parallel in lighting.

In the face of all these phenomena, how do audio professionals design subwoofer arrays and drive schemes that provide required qualities of coverage and fidelity?

If we succeed, then:
• The bass will be clear and will have constant tonal balance over the entire listening area.
• The bass sound level will be in correct balance with the midrange and high-frequency over the entire listening area.
• Negative effects of reverberation and reflection will be minimized.
• Efficiency of the equipment (sound power output per unit cost) will be maximized.

This article offers concepts and techniques for getting good bass. Our focus will be the frequency range from approximately 20 Hz to 150 Hz.

Wavelength
Just about everything having to do with loudspeaker array acoustics is relative to wavelength. A box or array is “large” if its dimensions—or some of its dimensions—are more than about 1.5 wavelengths across. A dimension is “small” if its dimensions are less than about a third of a wavelength.

Here are some typical wavelengths:

image

 
For normal air temperature, pressure, and humidity, the formulas for wavelength are:

image


Comments (8) Most recent displayed first | All comments in chronological order
Posted by brad000123  on  10/22/11  at  03:01 AM
Posted by brad000143  on  09/27/11  at  07:54 AM
“Thanks to our distributors’ tireless efforts and commitment, EAW, Martin Audio, Ampeg and Mackie sales in APAC are substantially ahead of our 2010 pace, and outpace other regions’ growth by three times,” says Sheena. “With increased in-market resources, faster decision making, stronger marketing support, and greatly intensified region-specific strategies, there’s no limit to what we will do together.” 70-515
Posted by marinarobert  on  09/07/11  at  03:54 AM
I don't think that light eperiences comb filtering. Is there a case where we perceive two sources of light to cancel each other?

70-642

70-643

70-646

70-647

70-648

70-649

70-652

70-653

Posted by Jeff Berryman  on  07/14/10  at  07:30 PM
Light can have comb filtering if it's coherent. Lasers produce coherent light, of course, which is why they're used in holography. Both holograms and the images they produce are interference / comb filtering patterns.

About reflection, I would tend to say that it's more like an echo than reverb. Of course, you could say that reverb is nothing more than a whole lot of superimposed multi-bounce echoing. So I guess that in a room full of mirrors, you could have actual optical reverb. Because of the speed of light, the decay time would probably be in the microsecond range.

Posted by Charles  on  07/13/10  at  07:35 PM
Going on the polarization tangent, reflection polarizes too, so hypothetically you could cancel light reflected off the stage using polarized sunglasses. That however wouldn't equal our issue of unintended cancelation, due to energy vs air pressure.

+ View all comments on this article

Commenting is not available in this weblog entry.